Structural Improvements Committee (SIC) Meeting - Minutes
SIC Members: Sébastien Bachollet, Bill Graham, Ray Plzak – Chair
Apologies: Wolfgang Kleinwächter and Kuo-Wei Wu
Other Board Member Attendees: Chris Disspain, Olga Madruga-Forti, Erika Mann, and George Sadowsky
Executive and Staff Attendees: Susana Bennett, Megan Bishop, Michelle Bright, Xavier Calvez, Larisa Gurnick, Jamie Hedlund, Alice Jansen, John Jeffrey, Jacks Khawaja, Denise Michel, David Olive, Erika Randall, Amy Stathos, and Theresa Swinehart
The following is a summary of discussions, decisions, and actions identified:
The Meeting was called to order at 11:00 local time Santa Monica, California.
- Agenda: The Chair established the agenda for the meeting and gave an overview of items to be discussed.
- Approval of Minutes: The Chair noted that the minutes from the 15 November 2013 were approved online.
Organizational Effectiveness Audit/Review: The Chair stated that the Bylaws require certain reviews of ICANN's structure, and made a presentation to the SIC of a proposed "audit" approach to undertake the structural reviews. The Chair discussed elements of different types of audits (outcome, structural and process element audits), and how they may be used to assist the overall effectiveness of the organization. The SIC considered potential elements of an audit or review mechanism, including the methods and tools, and qualitative and quantitative metrics. The Chair noted that the outputs could be fed into the work of other Board committees, such as the Audit Committee or the Risk Committee. The members of the SIC discussed whether the proposed approach would overlap with the overall organizational assessment that is part of the ATRT review. The SIC also discussed the implications of using the term "audit" to identify the structural review, and discussed the importance of ensuring that any review (or "audit") meets the requirements in the Bylaws. Some members of the Committee noted the concerns expressed by the community about the number of reviews underway, and the SIC considered whether efficiencies can be identified to reduce the potential burden of the various reviews scheduled.
- Staff to prepare an inventory and assessment of current reviews to provide insight into whether efficiencies exist.
- AOB: The chair noted that the SIC would postpone consideration of other agenda items until its next meeting.
The Chair called the meeting to a close.
Published on 21 March 2014