Logo
ICANN
ICANN
Filtered Search

Are you sure you want to sign out from https://www.icann.org?

If you want to sign out from both https://www.icann.org and ICANN Account, click here.

Public Comment

Public Comment is a vital part of our multistakeholder model. It provides a mechanism for stakeholders to have their opinions and recommendations formally and publicly documented. It is an opportunity for the ICANN community to effect change and improve policies and operations.

Ce contenu est uniquement disponible en

  • English

Name: Barkha Manral
Date: 23 Nov 2024
Email: [email protected]
Original Public Comment: Proposed Internet Coordination Policy 2 (ICP-2) Version 2 Principles
1) Do you agree with the Authority principle as set forth in the Proposed ICP-2 (v2) Principles document?
Agree
2) Do you agree with the Amendment principle as set forth in the Proposed ICP-2 (v2) Principles document?
Agree
4) Do you agree with the Coverage principle as set forth in the Proposed ICP-2 (v2) Principles document?
Agree
5) Do you agree with the Service Region principle as set forth in the Proposed ICP-2 (v2) Principles document?
Agree
6) Do you agree with the Recognition principle as set forth in the Proposed ICP-2 (v2) Principles document?
Agree
7) Do you agree with the Operation principle as set forth in the Proposed ICP-2 (v2) Principles document?
Agree
8) Do you agree with the Derecognition principle as set forth in the Proposed ICP-2 (v2) Principles document?

Please share any additional comments you have on this principle:

Public Comment on the Derecognition of RIRs I strongly support the principles outlined regarding the derecognition of Regional Internet Registries (RIRs), particularly the focus on remedial bias and the handoff process. It is crucial that ICANN, along with other RIRs, offers comprehensive support to any RIR facing compliance issues with ICP-2. This proactive approach ensures that RIRs have a fair opportunity to address and resolve problems before the derecognition process is initiated. Equally vital is the requirement for a seamless handoff process. In cases of derecognition, it is essential for the affected RIR to collaborate with ICANN and other RIRs to ensure the smooth transition of operations to a successor or interim entity. This will help preserve stability, continuity, and confidence in the global Internet governance framework. By establishing a clear and structured approach to derecognition, these provisions safeguard the integrity of the RIR system while providing the necessary support for remediation and transition. This approach will allow the community to maintain a strong, effective network management structure. Thank you for considering this critical aspect of the derecognition process. I look forward to further discussions on this important matter.

9) Do you agree with the Community Support principle as set forth in the Proposed ICP-2 (v2) Principles document?
Agree
10) Do you agree with the Community Commitment principle as set forth in the Proposed ICP-2 (v2) Principles document?
Agree
11) Do you agree with the Independence principle as set forth in the Proposed ICP-2 (v2) Principles document?
Neutral
12) Do you agree with the Not-for-Profit principle as set forth in the Proposed ICP-2 (v2) Principles document?
Neutral
13) Do you agree with the Corporate Governance principle as set forth in the Proposed ICP-2 (v2) Principles document?
Agree
14) Do you agree with the Member-Controlled principle as set forth in the Proposed ICP-2 (v2) Principles document?
Agree
15) Do you agree with the Community-Driven principle as set forth in the Proposed ICP-2 (v2) Principles document?
Neutral
16) Do you agree with the Neutrality principle as set forth in the Proposed ICP-2 (v2) Principles document?
Neutral
17) Do you agree with the Transparency principle as set forth in the Proposed ICP-2 (v2) Principles document?
Neutral
18) Do you agree with the Audit principle as set forth in the Proposed ICP-2 (v2) Principles document?
Neutral
19) Do you agree with the Service principle as set forth in the Proposed ICP-2 (v2) Principles document?
Agree
20) Do you agree with the Continuity principle as set forth in the Proposed ICP-2 (v2) Principles document?
Agree
21) Do you agree with the Anti-Capture principle as set forth in the Proposed ICP-2 (v2) Principles document?
Agree
22) Do you agree with the Ecosystem Stability principle as set forth in the Proposed ICP-2 (v2) Principles document?
Agree
23) Do you agree with the Remedial Bias principle as set forth in the Proposed ICP-2 (v2) Principles document?
Agree
24) Do you agree with the Handoff principle as set forth in the Proposed ICP-2 (v2) Principles document?
Neutral